Why Every Multi-Owner Business Needs a Buy-Sell Agreement

By Jaye Mankelow

In a multi-owner business, managing ownership transitions can be complex, especially if an owner unexpectedly departs due to illness, death, or personal decisions.

A buy-sell agreement outlines clear terms for ownership transfer, ensuring fair compensation, business continuity, and reduced potential for conflict. Here’s why a buy-sell agreement is essential for multi-owner businesses and what it should cover.

What is a Buy-Sell Agreement?

A buy-sell agreement is a legally binding contract between business co-owners that establishes the terms for transferring ownership interests when certain events occur, such as an owner’s death, disability, retirement, or decision to sell their share. The agreement defines how ownership will be bought and sold, protecting the business from unexpected disruptions.

• Ownership Transition Clarity: This agreement offers clear guidance on how ownership shares will be transferred, protecting both the business and the departing owner’s family.
• Financial Security for Families: Buy-sell agreements can provide family members of a departing owner with timely, fair compensation, avoiding disputes over business valuation or ownership rights.

Example: A multi-owner construction company may include in its buy-sell agreement that, upon the death of an owner, the remaining partners have the first right to purchase the shares at a predetermined valuation, ensuring the business remains within the original partnership.

Funding a Buy-Sell Agreement: Insurance, Financing, and Cash Flow

Funding the buy-sell agreement is essential to ensure that all owners have the means to buy out a departing owner. Common funding options include insurance, financing arrangements, and retained business earnings.

• Insurance Policies: Life or disability insurance policies on each owner’s life provide funds to buy out shares in case of death or incapacity. This allows the business to pay the departing owner’s family fairly without affecting cash flow.
• Financing Options: The agreement may also be funded through a financing plan, where the remaining owners purchase shares over time, balancing the business’s financial health with the need for ownership transition.
• Cash Flow Considerations: For businesses that generate steady cash flow, a buy-sell agreement funded by retained earnings may be feasible, though this approach is generally more suitable for larger, established companies.

Example: A manufacturing company with three owners may opt for a life insurance-funded buy-sell agreement, ensuring each owner’s family receives fair compensation without placing a financial burden on the company.

Handling Valuation Disputes

Valuing a business accurately can be challenging, and disagreements over valuation often lead to conflict. A buy-sell agreement should include a predefined valuation method to reduce disputes and ensure consistency.

• Valuation Methods: Common methods include fixed value (updated regularly), formula-based (e.g., earnings multiple), or appraisal-based, where an independent appraiser determines the value.
• Regular Valuation Updates: Setting up regular business valuations, or defining a formula that reflects the business’s growth, helps ensure valuations remain current and fair to all owners.
• Conflict Minimisation: By agreeing on a valuation method upfront, owners can avoid lengthy, contentious negotiations, maintaining business harmony even during transitions.

Tip: Including a formula-based or regularly appraised value in the buy-sell agreement helps ensure that owners and families are treated fairly, avoiding delays caused by valuation disputes.

Protecting Business Continuity and Stability

A buy-sell agreement safeguards business continuity by defining ownership transfer terms in cases of unexpected events, ensuring minimal disruption to operations.

• Avoiding Ownership Conflicts: Without a buy-sell agreement, the departing owner’s family may inherit shares, potentially leading to conflicts over business direction. A buy-sell agreement prevents this by ensuring shares go to the remaining owners or predetermined parties.
• Maintaining Operational Stability: Clear ownership transition terms help the business continue operating smoothly, even when an unexpected departure occurs, minimising disruption for employees, clients, and suppliers.

Example: An IT consultancy firm uses a buy-sell agreement to ensure that if one owner wants to exit the business, the remaining partners can purchase the shares, preventing any unplanned or external ownership.

A buy-sell agreement is crucial for every multi-owner business. It provides a roadmap for ownership transitions, secures financial compensation for families, and protects the business’s continuity.

Whether funded through insurance or financing arrangements, a well-drafted buy-sell agreement offers clarity, structure, and fairness. It ensures stability and reduces potential conflict among owners.

Aspira’s team of business advisors can help you establish a buy-sell agreement tailored to your needs. They will work with your legal and financial professionals to ensure all parties are protected. Contact us to discuss how a buy-sell agreement can safeguard your business and family interests.

Return to Business Insights Hub

‍